When you haven't got a poker face
My face shows exactly what I'm thinking at all times -- not the greatest for surprise events or even to keep my players from guessing the right moves. I learned how to solve this years ago, however.
I grin like a banshee through the whole game.
Try it -- not only does it keep your players from knowing what's going on, it unnerves some of them so they're not so darn cocky. :grin: