Reviews and Advice
[Advice] Advertising Your Site
A compilation of how to drive traffic to your game:
Advertise:
Post a link at RPG Gateway in the appropriate category.
Advertise your PBeM at PBeM2.com
[FAQ] Amber Quill Minimum Criteria
The Amber Quill is designed to recognize quality creative writing, rather than factual, resource-based content. In English, it recognizes exciting, involved and fluid game play rather than rules and background. Only actual game play logs (or archives) are considered for the AQ award.
Note to site owners: These are not artistic guidelines, but rather a set of minimum requirements. Do not submit your site (for the AQ award) until it meets these criteria. Then, please submit it for review by our Editors, who will then look over the content, originality, usefulness, creativity and effort put into the site to make a final determination. Thank you!
[FAQ] Gold Wyrm Minimum Criteria
The Gold Wyrm is an award for well-designed, well-thought and well-presented RPG content.
Note to site owners: These are not artistic guidelines, but rather a set of minimum requirements. Do not submit your site (for the GW award) until it meets these criteria. Then, please submit it for review by our Editors, who will then look over the content, originality, usefulness, creativity and effort put into the site to make a final determination. Thank you!
Site Content
- Content should be at least 90% original, with explicit attribution of non-original content.
- Site must show correct grammar, spelling, and nO teXt liKE ThIS or 133+ ("leet" speak). [Casual use of language is acceptable on boards, comment pages and the like. It is not acceptable for base content.]
[Rules] For Requesting a Review ... Please read
Hi, if you're wondering how your website is faring, ask here!
- Make sure to post your full site name and URL.
- Put your site URL in your subject line, please. A subject of "Review, please" is redundant -- we know you're here for a review

Dark World RPG- GW Review
I would like to submit the Dark World RPG pbem website for the Gold Wrym review. You can find the site located here:
Thank you.
plz help
tryin to strat an rpg site...but i dont noi where to start.. anywhere i can make a brower based rpg? or a rpg forum...?? w/ a tutorial would be cool... thanks for the help
New Age Descendants http://s15.zetaboards.com/New_Age_Descendants/
Here's a hotlink directly to the site: NAD
Please, I want real criticism. This mostly was a venture into a different style of writing, one that details the backstory of a "game".
Mafiacrime
Come check out the BEST Mafia RPG Ever made!
http://www.mafiacrime.org/r.php?id=5320
250 FREE Pts Just for singing up!! SHWEEET!
http://www.altfuture.com
Hi all,
Please can you review my onlne game, altfuture.com
It is in beta at the moment, though I hope to make it fully live after some tweaks.
Thanks
New York by Night www.nybn.org
My wife and I run a PbP game based on the OWoD ruleset. We would be greatly appreciative of any advice (or compliments
) some of you more seasoned web gurus can give. Please keep in mind that the mood of the game is supposed to be dark and a bit forboding.
Review Request - Obsidian Arena
Would like a some feedback on my website.
The game is computer moderated.
http://suicidolt.googlepages.com/Roller1.html
I read the rules, and only just joined the forums. Here's the short of it. This isn't (yet) a site per-say. It's more of a tool. This is my D&D dice
roller. I am posting it here because I want as much feedback as possible to improve it. 1) I am no artist. The art-work isn't mine. 2) It works best in firefox, and, despite w3c compliance I cannot figure out why it doesn't work properly in IE. Additionally, I tried to look over other sites, but found that there was nothing I could say that wasn't already said. By the level of coding here, my advice would be sub-par.
PbP doldrums
All PbP sites go through peaks and valleys, but perusing the links lately I have noticed that many very popular and until recently very active PbP sites have slumped, the faithful keep logging in, but there is nothing sadder than only 2 players rping when a board once boasted 30. So here are some hints to perhaps help revitalize your site, break the doldrums and even make the old players return
The Nine Worlds http://the9worlds.freeforums.org/portal.php
Just started this site, very recently looking for any advice or suggestions. My category is play by post, high fantasy, though there are steam-punk and post-apocalyptic scenarios. Not ready for a GW or a AQ yet, but with some solid active members any thing is possible.
http://hunted.charmedtvs.org/ The Hunted
Site name: The Hunted
Site url: http://hunted.charmedtvs.org/
I have this horror role-playing game that I have been trying to get off the ground, it's off to a slow but steady start and I'm quite proud of what's been accomplished so far. A good review will help me get some perspective on what may be seen as great or you can let me know needs to be added. Any advice, suggestions, praise (lol) will be appreciated. Looking forward to some insightful reviews!